10 Superhero Movies That Divided Audiences And Critics, According To Rotten Tomatoes


With the upcoming release of highly anticipated films such as Thor: Love and Thunder (July 8) and black adam (21st of October) Superhero movies have continually proven to be a staple in Hollywood. As audiences flock to see them and critics are intrigued by what Hollywood’s biggest movies have to offer, superhero films always receive plenty of reviews, comments and opinions from fans and critics.

While fans and critics are normally pretty close in their opinions of these films, there have been many times (as shown by the Tomatometer and Audience Score on Rotten Tomatoes) where a rift has formed between audiences and superhero movie reviews.


ten Man of Steel (Tomatometer: 56%/Audience Score: 75%)

Superman is completely angry in Man Of Steel

Zack Snyder’s reimagined version of Superman set a darker, more serious tone than fans had seen before in the original Superman films. While offering a new and fresh way to tell Clark Kent’s origin story (much to the delight of fans), the film itself provided an outdated, monotonous Superman that many reviewers singled out.

Related: Superman’s 10 Best Villains, According To Ranker

The film’s broad scope and spectacle won over many fans and led them to praise Zack Snyder’s vision for a modern take on Superman, but critics acknowledged that Clark Kent lacked the charisma and charm that were essential to the role. of Superman, which made for a fairly bland entry into the superhero genre.

9 X-Men: Apocalypse (Tomatometer: 46%/Audience score: 65%)

Apocalypse looking at a skull in the X-Men movie.

There is no doubt that X-Men: Apocalypse marked the beginning of the end of Fox’s ownership of Marvel’s Mutant Family. With a bland, underdeveloped villain and some very questionable plot decisions, the film received mostly lackluster reviews from critics.

Despite its performance with critics, there were enough fan-pleasing moments, such as Cyclops and Nightcrawler joining the team and Jean Gray displaying her full power, which caused the film to receive a lukewarm response from the mainstream. majority of fans.

8 Joker (Tomatometer: 68%/Audience score: 88%)

Cropped Fandango Joker Movie Poster

While critics and fans agree that Joaquin Phoenix’s Oscar-winning performance in Joker was well deserved, the film’s tone and social ideology divided critics and audiences alike. Many fans loved the film’s dark tone and enjoyed it. Joker was a darker and unique entry compared to the typical superhero movie.

Many critics felt that the film’s message merely pretended to make sense while acknowledging that the film was good but not as good as mainstream audiences think. Thinking of himself as the hero of his own story, Arthur Fleck may be far from a true superhero, but Joker received as much fan praise as any other blockbuster superhero film.

seven Zack Snyder’s Justice League (Tomatometer: 71% / Audience Score: 94%)

Zack Snyder's Justice League poster showing the team in black and white

It’s safe to say that Zack Snyder’s Justice League was an improvement in every way over the original and this was greatly reflected in both its audience and critics’ rating. While most critics thought the movie was solid and worth the remake, fans were blown away because Zack Snyder’s Justice League would receive the highest viewership score of any DCEU film.

Giving each of its characters better story arcs and fleshing out Steppenwolf as a villain, reviewers found the film acceptable but nothing special. However, many comic book fans were completely blown away by the film’s final battle.

6 Justice League (Tomatometer: 39% / Audience Score: 68%)

Many fans were excited to finally see the Justice League on the big screen, and while it would show in the viewership score, many critics felt the movie wasn’t entertaining and many characters lacked depth and depth. of emotion.

Related: 10 Best Batman Villains Fans Must See In A Live-Action Movie

While it’s true that Justice League was a box office flop, most of that could be attributed to the studio and post-production issues the film was having and although the majority of audiences found it to be a fairly enjoyable superhero blockbuster, critics were not as passive of the film’s flaws.

5 Glass (Tomatometer: 36%/Audience score: 67%)

End of drink credits scene

As a superhero movie unrelated to Marvel or DC, Glass director M. Knight Shyamalan had the potential to create its own universe centered around individuals with extraordinary abilities. While critics and audiences agreed that James McAvoy delivered one of his best performances in the film, their reviews of the film itself were pretty split (no pun intended).

Many critics were disappointed with the film and believe that Shyamalan focused too much on the twist instead of forming a compelling story while audiences got the impression that McAvoy’s performance with Bruce Willis and Samuel L. Jackson made the movie enjoyable enough but not great.

4 Eternals (Tomatometer: 47% / Audience score: 78%)

Eternals Spaceship Header

As the only MCU film to ever receive a rotten score on Rotten Tomatoes, Eternals is one of the most controversial MCU films to date. Arguing that the movie is bogged down with too many characters, a fuzzy story, and some of the MCU’s worst villains to date, many critics couldn’t find much to praise other than a few visually impressive shots.

The majority of MCU fans were able to see past these flaws and appreciate the new scope. Eternals brought to the MCU with some pretty satisfying character moments made the movie a solid entry with mainstream audiences, but that doesn’t save Eternals to be the lowest rated film in the MCU.

3 Captain Marvel (Tomatometer: 79% / Audience Score: 45%)

Captain Marvel on his movie poster.

While it’s true Captain Marvel was a very impressive performance at the box office, there were haters of Brie Larson who didn’t like the movie as much. A 79% Tomatoes score is only slightly below average for an MCU film, but a 45% Audience score is the lowest of any MCU film.

Related: 10 MCU Heroes’ Biggest Power Displays

Perhaps Captain Marvel’s emotionless and overpowered nature made it too difficult for general audiences to relate to the character, but as the MCU’s first female-led film, many critics praised it. Captain Marvel to be a breakthrough film in the superhero genre.

2 Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (Tomatometer: 29%/Audience Score: 63%)

Trinity Unites To Fight Doomsday In Batman V Superman Dawn Of Justice

There is no doubt that Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice was one of the most anticipated films of all time. With numerous previews and sold-out opening nights, the film’s enormous potential fell flat with audiences, but hit rock bottom with critics.

While the film attempted to touch on some pretty powerful subjects such as the fallout from Superman’s battle in Metropolis, the overcrowded plot as well as unlikable versions of Batman and Superman made the film one of the super movies. -lowest rated heroes of all time. Despite this, many comic book fans have found some enjoyment in seeing characters such as Wonder Woman and Doomsday appear on the big screen.

1 Dark Phoenix (Tomatometer: 22% / Audience Score: 64%)

dark phoenix was Fox’s second attempt at the popular comic book saga of the same name and while some fans weren’t thrilled with the film, the majority of audiences found dark phoenix to have the internal conflict that makes the story work.

However, critics couldn’t see past the emotionless and clichéd villains, poor writing, and controversial plot decisions, resulting in the film receiving one of the lowest critical scores ever. for a big-budget superhero movie. As Fox’s final X-Men era film, dark phoenixThe mixed reception from the general public could not prevent the film from being a critical and financial disappointment.

Next: 10 Crossover Fights MCU & DCEU Fans Would Love To See

Shared image of Uma Thurman and Ansel Elgort in their respective films Kill Bill and Baby Driver

10 Times An Actor Mastered A Skill For A Movie Role, According To Ranker

About the Author

Source link


About Author

Comments are closed.